Film · Culture · Perspective
TheHollywood NorthWhat landed. What didn’t. What stayed.
Vancouver, B.C. and beyond

Review · 2009

Brooklyn's FinestThree Clocks, No Clean Way Out

Brooklyn’s Finest poster

My rating6/10

Brooklyn's Finest worked for me largely because the cast never lets the movie down, even when the structure feels heavy. The story that pulled me in most was Sal Procida (Ethan Hawke - Training Day, Before the Devil Knows You're Dead). From the opening moments, his desperation feels lived-in rather than manufactured, and once that pressure starts building, it never really lets up. Hawke plays him as a man already negotiating with himself, which makes every decision feel both inevitable and uncomfortable.

Tango (Don Cheadle - Traffic, Hotel Rwanda) and Eddie Dugan (Richard Gere - American Gigolo, Pretty Woman) are just as effective, though they take longer to settle. Gere's storyline especially started off feeling the dullest to me, almost like a holding pattern, but by the end it becomes the connective tissue that brings all three arcs together. Watching it unfold slowly actually pays off, turning his character into the emotional hinge of the film rather than an afterthought.

Seeing Tango share the screen with Caz (Wesley Snipes - New Jack City, Blade) was a highlight. The film sells their bond through implication rather than exposition, which mostly works, but I did find myself wanting more. The "incident" that supposedly saved Tango's life is referenced but never shown, and it feels like it must have been significant for him to risk his entire career to avenge someone he's supposed to be bringing down - "friend" used loosely here, since he's still a cop. That missing context stood out.

Will Patton (No Way Out, Armageddon), as always, fits seamlessly into his role. He has that rare ability to feel exactly right in these worlds without drawing attention to himself, reinforcing the film's grounded tone.

Gere's Eddie getting entangled with a sex worker also carries an unintended bit of irony. Another Richard Gere character getting pulled into that situation - but this time, Pretty Woman rules don't apply, and the consequences are far less forgiving.

By the time all three storylines converge, the movie justifies its runtime. The final act gives weight to everything that came before it, and the moral choices land harder because you've lived with each character long enough to understand what they're giving up. Eddie, in particular, ended up being the one I related to most. The "just a few more days and I'm out of here" mindset is familiar, and the film earns the moment where he finally chooses what's right over what's easy.

I also couldn't help but notice how much Sal resembles Alonzo Harris (Denzel Washington - Training Day) when riding shotgun during training. Whether intentional or not, it felt like a quiet visual echo.

First published on IMDb. Original IMDb review ↗